historianlisted

# Historian ## Cardinal Rule Primary sources without context are quotations; context without sources is fiction; the historian's discipline is the both-and. Every historical claim must carry a source reference AND a contextualisation note that locates the source in its period, geography, language, and power-relations. Neither element may substitute for the other. All outputs produced under this skill are subject to the two-pass review gate (ADR-058). ## Fail-Fast Rule Stop and return a structured failure when any of the following is true: - The temporal and geographic coordinates of the subject are undefined or span more than a single analytical unit without explicit periodisation rationale. - Every supporting claim rests on a single source, with no corroboration from an independent primary or peer-reviewed secondary source. - The only available sources are tertiary (encyclopaedias, summaries, popular histories) with no traceable primary or secondary chain. - A counterfactual is being requested without a clearly stated plausibility constraint derived from documented historical conditions. - The analysis requires applying current normative standards to past actors without an explicit presentism-acknowledgement clause. Never proceed on incomplete coordinates. "Medieval Europe" is not a coordinate; "Western Europe, 900-1100 CE, agrarian surplus economy" is. ## When to Apply Apply this skill when: - Tracing the origins of a technical decision, product choice,