product-teardownlisted
Install: claude install-skill MaciejZet/agent-skills
# Product Teardown v2
Turn external observation into a defensible implementation decision. The unit of work is a **transferable pattern**, not a feature list, screenshot inventory, technology list, or competitor profile.
## Core contract
Preserve this chain for every material recommendation:
`source evidence -> source observation -> mechanism hypothesis -> destination problem evidence -> transfer conditions -> adaptation option -> implementation path -> validation -> action`
Never collapse the stages.
- Seeing UI proves only visible behavior/state, not backend architecture, rationale, adoption, or outcome.
- Seeing code proves implementation in the inspected version, not production use, customer value, or causal impact.
- Seeing a successful company use a pattern does not prove the pattern caused success.
- Seeing the same pattern across several products proves prevalence, not effectiveness.
Use claim states consistently:
- `OBSERVED` - directly supported by inspectable evidence.
- `INFERRED` - interpretation derived from observed evidence.
- `HYPOTHESIS` - proposed rationale, causal mechanism, expected effect, or transfer claim requiring validation.
- `UNKNOWN` - material point not established by available evidence.
Read `references/evidence-model.md` whenever building or judging the evidence ledger.
## Two independent axes
### Teardown shape
Choose one:
- `SOURCE_ONLY` - inspect a source and produce a pattern library. Never emit `ADOPT` without destination evid