writing-craftlisted
Install: claude install-skill Ptlimited/writing-craft
# writing-craft
Nine traits, taken from what three independent blind judges said separated the best
writing from the worst across 50 pieces. Applied while drafting, then checked before the
draft is returned.
The rules are not style preferences. Each one is what a judge wrote down, unprompted by
any supplied vocabulary, after scoring 50 files down columns without knowing who wrote
what. See "Where these came from" at the end.
## How to use this skill
1. **Read the nine rules below before drafting.** They shape the draft. They are not a
post-hoc edit pass.
2. **Draft.**
3. **Run the gate.** `python3 <skill>/check.py <draft-file>`. Add `--hooks` for hook
lists, where hedging is zero-tolerance.
4. **Fix what fails, re-check.** Up to two revision passes.
5. **Return the draft with the check report.** If anything still fails after two passes,
say so plainly rather than shipping it quietly.
Never claim a judgment rule passed without saying what you concluded. Never return a
draft that failed a mechanical check without naming the failure.
---
## The nine rules
### 1. Specificity only someone who did it would have
A number, an incident, a duration, a witnessed detail. Ninety lines. Forty minutes.
Three separate reminders about em-dashes. One task in ten. The top scorers all carry at
least one detail that would be pointless to invent. The bottom ones speak entirely in
category: "routine work", "genuinely complex problems", "a lot of people".
**This cannot be checked