← ClaudeAtlas

comparelisted

Rank all the ideas evaluated with kill-my-idea in this project, from their verdict.json files, recommend which ONE to focus on this week, and write the idea dashboard (ideas/board.html) and the brain note (ideas/BRAIN.md). With --refresh, re-research stale verdicts before ranking. Use when the user says "compare my ideas", "which idea should I do", "rank my ideas", "what should I focus on", "refresh", "update the ranking", or has evaluated 2 or more ideas.
RemiPelloux/kill-my-idea · ★ 2 · AI & Automation · score 68
Install: claude install-skill RemiPelloux/kill-my-idea
# Compare Ideas ## Options - **`--refresh`** (also when the user says "refresh" or "update the ranking"): re-research stale verdicts before ranking (step 2). Without it, compare only reads the verdicts. This option was requested by a user, so a ranking built on old research can be brought up to date in one command. - **`--refresh all`** (or "refresh all of them"): refresh every verdict, stale or not. ## Steps 1. **Find the verdicts.** Read every `ideas/*/verdict.json` (and `idea.json`) in the current project. - Fewer than 2 found → say so, and suggest `/kill-my-idea:kill`. - A verdict whose `evaluated` date is more than 90 days before today is **stale**. Without `--refresh`, mark it and suggest `/kill-my-idea:compare --refresh`. - A verdict whose `confidence.level` is `low` is marked **low confidence**: its rank is provisional. 2. **Refresh (only with `--refresh`).** For each stale verdict (or every verdict with `--refresh all`), one idea at a time or one subagent per idea: 1. Copy the current `mode`, `evaluated`, `score`, `verdict` and source count into a new entry at the end of `verdict.history`. 2. Rerun the kill skill's research steps 3–5 for that idea (`${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/skills/kill/SKILL.md`), with its safety rules (§0) and source minimums. Keep `idea.json` as it is; the user's answers still hold. 3. Update `verdict.json`: `evaluated` = today, the metrics, sub-scores, score, rules, confidence, kill