← ClaudeAtlas

researchzy-paper-reviewlisted

Review a manuscript the way its reviewers will: claims against evidence, numbers against tables, novelty against real papers, findings with verified quotes and minimal fixes, two readiness verdicts, no score. Use before submission, or to draft a referee report on someone else's paper.
Researchzy/Researchzy-academic-skills · ★ 0 · Code & Development · score 72
Install: claude install-skill Researchzy/Researchzy-academic-skills
# Researchzy Paper Review This skill reviews a manuscript as a careful referee would. It sets the claims the paper rests on against the evidence for each, audits the numbers against the tables and figures, tests claims of novelty against papers a search returned, and writes findings that each quote the manuscript, name the smallest sufficient fix and say how to tell that it is closed. It ends with two verdicts, one on the science and one on submission. It gives no score and does not predict acceptance. It does not polish grammar, style or LaTeX (that is `researchzy-writing`), does not rewrite the paper, and does not simulate a panel of reviewers. You judge; the bundled script checks. It confirms that every quote is in the manuscript and that the verdicts do not contradict the findings, and only then writes the report. Resolve `SKILL_DIR` to the directory containing this `SKILL.md`. The script needs Python 3.10 or newer and nothing else; reading a PDF needs PyMuPDF. No account is needed. With the `researchzy` plugin connected, step 5 also searches Researchzy's index. ## Two uses | | Own draft (default) | Referee report | |---|---|---| | The manuscript | The user's, before submission | Someone else's, under review | | Before reading | Nothing | Read [Referee mode](references/referee-mode.md): the user first confirms that the venue allows AI assistance | | Fixes | Proposed wording is welcome | Requests only; no rewriting | | Report | `review.md` | `referee-report.md` for th