review-planlisted

# compass:review-plan (Review-2 · FULL) Lens: **will this plan, built exactly as written, work — and break nothing else?** ## Step 0 — gate Run `compass.sh gate .claude/builds/<slug> plan`. **Non-zero → STOP**, offer `compass:plan`. Read `contract.md` + `plan.md`. Set `progress.md` = `in-review (R2)`. ## Engine - **Ledger** (create if absent): same columns as the other reviews. - **Material** = new Critical/Major. **Clean round** = zero new material AND the deterministic checks re-ran green. **Proof-of-work:** the footer carries evidence or it doesn't count — `> Round N (R2): checks=\`<cmd>\` exit=0; new Crit/Maj=0. Clean? yes`. **Converged = two consecutive clean rounds.** Cap **3**. <!-- BUGBAR:START --> - **Severity bug-bar — every ledger `Severity` cell MUST cite one clause.** **CRITICAL** — data loss/corruption · a security or commercial leak · a wrong number that ships · an unassertable INVARIANT · an irreversible migration · prod-down. **MAJOR** — wrong behavior with a workaround · a drift-prone duplicated canonical set · a missing guard on a reachable path. **MINOR** — cosmetic / log-wording. <!-- BUGBAR:END --> - **Self-refutation (before a Critical/Major counts):** in the Root-cause cell, record that the triggering input is **reachable from a real entry point** AND that it is **not already guarded** (no existing guard handles it); an unreachable or already-guarded finding is downgraded or dropped — it never resets convergence. - **Dedupe & rank:** collapse findi