← ClaudeAtlas

the-cruciblelisted

Run The Crucible (圆桌萃鉴), a rigorous evidence-backed multi-reviewer review. Configure a confirmed table, preserve separate first passes, mechanically compare per-item findings, adjudicate objections against primary evidence, and produce traceable consensus and unresolved decisions. Use when the user explicitly asks for The Crucible, a round table, panel, multiple independent reviewers, evidence-backed consensus, or a consequential review-gated batch write/import. Apply across domains and file types; do not invoke for an ordinary single-reviewer review.
SEKKAIE/the-crucible · ★ 2 · DevOps & Infrastructure · score 65
Install: claude install-skill SEKKAIE/the-crucible
# The Crucible · 圆桌萃鉴 Put claims, plans, and artifacts through separate evidence-based scrutiny. “萃鉴�� means that a judgment is distilled from distinct perspectives and evidence, then examined with discernment; treat the result as an evidence-adjudication process, not a vote. ## Configure the table before reviewing Do not begin substantive review or spawn reviewers until the table configuration is confirmed. 1. Perform only the lightweight, read-only scoping needed to understand the artifact, stakes, disciplines, evidence volume, and desired assurance. 2. Recommend a member count and explain why it fits the task: - 3 seats for the default full review: lead, evidence reviewer, and domain reviewer; - 4 seats when a dedicated risk, security, legal, or red-team perspective is materially useful; - 5 seats for high-stakes cross-disciplinary work that also needs a distinct operator, user-impact, or second specialist perspective; - 2 seats only as a clearly labeled lower-assurance peer review, not a full three-seat Round Table; - more than 5 only when the added domain coverage justifies the coordination cost. 3. List every proposed seat, its responsibility, why it is non-duplicative, and whether the seat authored or materially edited the artifact. 4. Present the configuration as a Markdown table, never as an unstructured paragraph: ```markdown ### The Crucible · 圆桌萃鉴 — Configuration Proposal **Review scope:** <artifact, claims, or decisions> **Assurance:** <full