← ClaudeAtlas

premise-checklisted

Check the premise of an idea before any design or build. Takes an idea, a feature request or a ready-made solution, traces each part of it back to who asked for it, states the need under it, and sorts the parts into P0, P1 and left out, with the one fact that would change the sorting. One pass with no questions. Use at the start of a design, when the user arrives with a solution in hand ("let's build X", "we need a Y", "like Z but for W"), when asked "is this worth building", "do we need this" or "triage my ideas", and on a list of ideas to sort. Not for an ML research idea (research-triage), not for finding what already exists (build-scout), and not for a bug, which already states its need.
SeanoChang/seanock · ★ 0 · AI & Automation · score 70
Install: claude install-skill SeanoChang/seanock
# premise-check An agent builds in hours what once took weeks, so a wrong idea no longer fails at the build. It fails later, after the design, the review and the tests were spent on it. The cheap moment to catch it is before the design starts. An idea usually arrives as a solution. Some of its parts answer a real need. Other parts came along because the user liked them in another tool. This skill separates the two, with proof for each, in the words the design will use afterwards: P0, P1, and left out on purpose. ## Input - **The idea,** in the user's own words. - **The source:** the text that says what is wanted. An assignment, a ticket, a spec, the user's notes or earlier messages. Read all of it first. Ask no questions. Where you must guess, guess, and mark it as a guess. ## Output Five parts, in this order, under these headings with their numbers. Part 3 is left out when it is empty. ### 1. Parts Split the idea into three to seven parts, each one a thing that would be built. Trace every part to where it comes from. A part has one source: when half of it is asked and half is borrowed, split it in two. | Part | Comes from | Proof | | --- | --- | --- | | Comes from | Meaning | Proof to give | | --- | --- | --- | | `asked` | The source asks for it | The quote, and where it is | | `seen` | A record shows the need: a log, a metric, an incident, a benchmark | The record | | `wanted` | The user wants it, and nothing records a need | The user's words | | `borrowed` | I