← ClaudeAtlas

swing-clarifylisted

Prevents premature execution on ambiguous requests. Analyzes request clarity using 5W1H decomposition, surfaces hidden assumptions, and generates structured clarifying questions before work begins. Use at the start of any non-trivial task, or when a request could be interpreted multiple ways. Triggers on "뭘 원하는건지", "요구사항 정리", "clarify", "what exactly", "scope", "requirements", "정확히 뭘", "before we start".
TheStack-ai/swing-skills · ★ 36 · Code & Development · score 77
Install: claude install-skill TheStack-ai/swing-skills
# Scope Clarifier Prevents the most common AI failure: rushing to execute before understanding what's actually needed. > Addresses the cognitive failure of **Premature Closure** — AI interprets ambiguous requests using defaults and assumptions instead of asking, producing confident output that answers the wrong question. ## Rules (Absolute) 1. **Never execute before clarifying.** If ambiguity score is above threshold, generate questions FIRST. Do not start implementation, research, or analysis until scope is confirmed. 2. **Maximum 3 questions.** Respect the user's time. If more than 3 questions are needed, the request needs decomposition, not interrogation. Ask the 3 highest-impact questions. 3. **Questions must be actionable.** Every question must change what you build. "What's your timeline?" is only valid if it affects scope. "Should this handle authentication?" is always valid if auth wasn't mentioned. 4. **Prefer multiple choice over open-ended.** "Should auth use (a) session cookies, (b) JWT, or (c) OAuth2 with a provider?" beats "How should auth work?" 5. **State your default assumption.** For each question, state what you WOULD assume if the user doesn't answer. This lets them skip questions where the default is fine. 6. **Clear requests get a green light, not questions.** If the request is unambiguous, say so and proceed. Do not ask questions for the sake of asking. 7. **Never block on style preferences.** Naming conventions, formatting, folder structure — thes