kiyaslisted
Install: claude install-skill XINMurat/Kiyas
# Kıyas — Disciplined Ideation and Analogical Inference
> **[Revised 2026-07-22 — A1–A4]** A 4-scenario test → 3 seeds → Mizan audit →
> prior-art lit-check cycle exposed and fixed three preregistration-hygiene
> gaps: (A1) prior-art declaration is mandatory and gates `[H-aday]`;
> (A2) capacity-confound control arm; (A3) instrument-specific calibration;
> (A4) trace base-rate prior (AD6). The analogical core did not change; what
> changed is the hygiene a candidate passes before entering Mizan.
> **[Revised 2026-08-20 — G10/G11]** The last two findings of
> `PROSE-SCHEMA-AUDIT.md`. G10 came from the sibling Mizan validator, which
> had caught the arbiter self-contradiction since R8 shipped — the two repos
> had each solved something the other had not, and comparing them was worth
> more than either audit alone.
> **[Revised 2026-08-19 — G8/G9 + warnings]** A systematic pass over this
> file against the schema (`PROSE-SCHEMA-AUDIT.md`) found two places where the
> data contract permitted what the prose forbids outright: an `[H-aday]` with
> no cheapest refutation (constraint 3), and an `[H-aday]` whose prior art was
> never searched (constraint 4 — G3 only ever covered the narrower
> superiority-claim gate). Both now block. The validator also gained a
> non-blocking warning channel, because a single blocking channel teaches
> authors to write batches that avoid triggering rules — G6's own lesson,
> applied to the tool.
> **[Revised 2026-08-19 — G7]** The discard list beca