← ClaudeAtlas

critic-reviewlisted

Reviews one QA pipeline stage's artefacts against a fixed rubric (toolkit/rubrics/*.md) as an independent critic, and records the verdict and every disagreement with evidence, so the engineer decides each one. Use after Gate 1 (requirements) and Gate 3 (automation code), when qa-orchestrator asks for a critic, or when the user asks for a second opinion on generated requirements or tests. Not for reviewing your own work in the same conversation.
YevheniiaQA/qa-agent-toolkit · ★ 0 · Code & Development · score 72
Install: claude install-skill YevheniiaQA/qa-agent-toolkit
# Critic review A stage agent checks its own work with its skill's self-check. That catches what the agent knows to look for; it cannot catch what the agent misunderstood, because the same reading produced both the artefact and the check. A critic reads the artefacts cold, against the sources and a rubric it did not write, and reports where it disagrees. It does not fix anything: every disagreement becomes a question for the engineer. ## Independence - **Work from the artefacts and the sources**, never from the stage agent's report, its conversation or its gate file's self-check. Open the gate file only after every rubric item is answered, and only to see which IDs and paths the stage claims. - **Another vendor's model is the strongest critic**, a local model the next, another model of the same vendor in a fresh context the weakest that still counts. `qa-critic record` works out `independence` (cross-vendor, local, same-vendor) from the critic's and the producer's models; report it as recorded. A same-vendor critic still catches omissions and unsourced values well; it shares the producer's blind spots on interpretation. - **Never review work you produced** in the same conversation. ## Procedure 1. Get the task: `qa-critic prompt <TICKET> <STAGE>` prints the rubric, the files to read and the output format. The rubric for a stage: requirements-decomposer → `rubrics/requirements.md`, automation-api / automation-ui → `rubrics/code.md`. 2. Answer every rubri