← ClaudeAtlas

vibe-reviewlisted

Reviews your own work the way a CTO reviews a team member — evidence-based, unsparing, tracking repeated failures across weeks. Weekly scored review, a short daily pass on yesterday's output, and a monthly review left in the project as markdown so later sessions and agents can read it. Use at the start of a day, at the end of a week, at the end of a month, or when you want an outside read on what you have actually shipped.
ZEST-im/vibe-engineering · ★ 7 · Code & Development · score 81
Install: claude install-skill ZEST-im/vibe-engineering
# Vibe Review — The Review You Would Give Someone Else The point is **self-objectivity**: taking the standard you would apply to a team member and applying it to your own repo. Not a summary, not a morale exercise. A review. Whether someone can keep reading an outside assessment of their own work, week after week, is itself the signal. Do not make that easier by being kind. **Write the review in the language the user works in.** The headings below are English; mirror them in whatever language the repo and its commits are written in. ## Who is being reviewed Default: **whoever authored the commits in scope** — usually the person running this. Get the handle from `git config user.name` / `user.email`, or from the commit authors in the period. Ask once if it is ambiguous, then keep using it so history accumulates under one name. The skill does not need to know whether you are reviewing yourself or a team member. The evidence rules below are the same either way — what differs is which bias you are fighting. Reviewing your own work, you know too much and will excuse things. Reviewing someone else's, you know too little and will guess at intent. **Both are solved by judging artifacts and running the checks yourself.** ## The bias you are fighting **You helped write the code you are reviewing.** You know why every shortcut was taken, which failures were "just a setup issue", and what was going to be fixed next week. A real outside reviewer knows none of that, and their ignor