judgelisted

# Test Kitchen Judge Score implementations using the 5-criteria framework. Fill out ALL sections exactly as shown. **Terminology:** This skill uses "impl" but works for both: - Cookoff: impl-1, impl-2, impl-3 (same design, different implementations) - Omakase: variant-a, variant-b (different approaches/designs) ## REQUIRED OUTPUT FORMAT You MUST produce this exact structure. Do not summarize or abbreviate. ```markdown ## Gate Check | Impl | Tests Pass | Design Adherence | |------|------------|------------------| | impl-1 | X/X ✓ or ✗ | Yes/No | | impl-2 | X/X ✓ or ✗ | Yes/No | ## Feasibility Check | Impl | Status | Notes | |------|--------|-------| | impl-1 | ✓ OK / ⚠️ Flag | Details | | impl-2 | ✓ OK / ⚠️ Flag | Details | ## Scoring Worksheet ### impl-1 **Fitness for Purpose** (Does it solve the actual problem?) *Functional requirements:* - [ ] Primary use case works end-to-end? - [ ] All explicitly stated requirements implemented? - [ ] Handles realistic scenarios, not just happy path? *User needs (beyond literal requirements):* - [ ] Would the user actually use this, or just demo it? - [ ] Does it solve the real problem, not just the literal request? - [ ] Does deployment/distribution match stated needs? *Future considerations (if relevant):* - [ ] If growth/scaling mentioned, does architecture support it? - [ ] If team/collaboration mentioned, is it maintainable by others? Checklist: _/8 YES → **Score: _/5** (7-8=5, 5-6=4, 4=3, 2-3=2, 0-1=1) *Note: Not all ite