← ClaudeAtlas

reviewinglisted

Structured critique of research, plan, and brainstorm documents for completeness, gaps, and quality.
desplega-ai/ai-toolbox · ★ 35 · Code & Development · score 71
Install: claude install-skill desplega-ai/ai-toolbox
# Reviewing You are performing a structured critique of a document (research, plan, or brainstorm) to identify gaps, weaknesses, and quality issues. (For reviewing a code diff, use `desplega:code-reviewing` instead — this skill reviews documents.) ## Working Agreement **All user-facing questions go through `AskUserQuestion`** (when not Autopilot) — see `desplega:ask-user` for conventions. Never ask in chat as plain bullets. File-review is on by default — invoke it after the automated review (skip only if Autopilot). ### Output Mode Unless Autopilot, ask once at the start: | Question | Options | |----------|---------| | "How should I present the review findings?" | 1. Append errata section to the document (Recommended), 2. Auto-apply fixes to the document, 3. Write a separate review file to thoughts/*/reviews/ | ## When to Use This skill activates when: - User invokes `/review` command - Another skill references the reviewing skill at completion - User asks to review, critique, or check a document ## Autonomy Mode At the start of review, adapt your interaction level based on the autonomy mode: | Mode | Behavior | |------|----------| | **Autopilot** | Run full review, auto-fix minor issues, present summary at end | | **Critical** (Default) | Ask about Critical/Important findings, auto-fix Minor ones | | **Verbose** | Walk through each finding, confirm before any changes | The autonomy mode is passed by the invoking command. If not specified, default to **Critical**