review-pr-commentslisted
Install: claude install-skill hcaiano/skills
# Review PR Comments
Handle real review feedback on an existing PR. This is an on-demand, exception
path: most PRs have no comments because cloud auto-review is disabled and the
heavy review already happened locally (ship-it's dual-review gate). Do not
summon bot reviews (`@codex review`, `@coderabbitai review`), and never treat a
bot's silence as something to wait for.
Process, at most TWO rounds (a round = collect → triage → one batched commit →
push → required CI green on the new head):
1. Collect all open feedback: human reviews, bot comments, unresolved and
outdated threads, failing checks.
2. Triage each finding against the code:
- **Fix in the batch:** real correctness, security, or data-integrity
issues, and anything a human reviewer explicitly requested.
- **Reply, don't push:** style nits, defensive hardening for invariants
that already hold, severity-inflated or duplicate findings. Answer the
thread, resolve it, move on. A nit is never a reason for a push.
- **Surface to the user:** product/architecture decisions, scope
expansions, conflicting reviewer guidance.
3. Validate the complete head (original changes plus fixes), commit and push
once, and wait for required CI (poll at 60–120 s intervals, never tight
loops).
After two rounds, stop pushing: report remaining items with your triage and
recommendation. Feedback arriving after your final push does not reopen the
loop. Success: required checks green on the final head, hum