rubric-panellisted

Score one or more code artifacts against an anchored rubric using a persona-diverse judge panel; produces dimension scores plus findings classified as defect, noise, spec-hole, or undeclared-commitment. Use when asked to "score this implementation", "judge these two solutions", "rate this module against a rubric", or compare competing implementations of the same spec, and when invoked by layer-cycle. For choosing between technologies, frameworks, or vendors, use tech-eval-research instead.
hsb3/dotfiles-agents · ★ 0 · AI & Automation · score 70

Install: claude install-skill hsb3/dotfiles-agents

# Rubric panel  In Codex, first read [Codex distribution](../delegation/references/dispatch-knobs.md#codex-distribution) for installed role setup, native dispatch, isolation prerequisites, and completion routing. That section supplies the Codex procedures wherever this workflow names Claude Code tools.  Judge the artifact, not the process. Score absolutely against anchors, never on a curve. ## Inputs (ask only for what's missing) - **targets** — artifact path(s), implementation + tests per unit. - **rubric** — anchored 1–5 dimensions with weights. None → offer a default (cold readability 20; idiomatic fit, signal-to-noise, architecture 15 each; type leverage, error-path robustness, test quality 10 each; extensibility 5). - **contract** — the behavioral spec; defines "externally observable" for finding classification. - Optional: panel size (default 3), personas (default: long-term maintainer, language purist, QA skeptic), effort level. ## Preconditions Run each target's gate first — never score broken code; report the gate failure instead. Judges are read-only. ## Process 1. Dispatch N parallel judge agents, one persona each — one dispatch per judge, all in a single turn so they run in parallel. Each is a read-only reviewer subagent with its persona carried in the prompt. **Every judge scores the whole field** — one judge across all targets keeps calibration consistent; N judges average out persona bia