← ClaudeAtlas

iw-review-designlisted

Reviews and validates a design package (Feature, Incident, or Change Request) for completeness, consistency, and compliance with IW workflow conventions. Then performs a substantive design critique. Fixes issues found. Use after creating a design package and before approving it. Triggers on "review design", "validate design", "check design", "/iw-review-design".
innovation-ways/iw-ai-core · ★ 0 · Code & Development · score 70
Install: claude install-skill innovation-ways/iw-ai-core
# Design Package Reviewer Validate, critique, and fix the design package for work item **$ARGUMENTS**. This review has two phases: 1. **Compliance Review** (Steps 1-5) — structural completeness, format, consistency 2. **Substantive Design Critique** (Step 6) — is the analysis correct and the solution sound? --- ## Step 1: Locate and Load the Package 1. Determine the work item ID from `$ARGUMENTS` (e.g., `I006`, `F124`, `CR002`) 2. Read all files in `ai-dev/active/{ID}/`: - Design document: `{ID}_*_Design.md` - Manifest: `workflow-manifest.json` - All prompts in `prompts/` - Evidence files in `evidences/pre/` (if any) 3. Also check current platform status: ```bash iw item-status $ARGUMENTS 2>/dev/null || echo "Not registered yet" ``` 4. Determine the work item type from the ID prefix: - `F` → Feature, `I` → Issue/Incident, `CR` → Change Request 5. Read the corresponding template for the type: - Feature: `ai-dev/templates/Feature_Design_Template.md` - Issue: `ai-dev/templates/Issue_Design_Template.md` - CR: `ai-dev/templates/CR_Design_Template.md` ## Step 2: Validate the Design Document Check the design document against its template. Every required section must be present and non-empty. ### Common Checks (all types) - [ ] **Metadata block** present (Type, Created, Status; plus type-specific fields: Priority/Severity/Reason, Reported By for Issues) - [ ] **Description** section is non-empty (at least 2 sentences) - [ ] **Project Context*