pm-evaluatorlisted

# PM evaluator Grades a PM artifact against the five-criterion rubric in `rubrics/pm-evaluation-rubric.md`. Designed to give honest, specific, actionable critique — not a hagiographic review. ## When to use Use this when: - The user shares a strategy memo, PRD, recommendation deck, or product analysis and asks for critique - The user is about to send something up the chain and wants a pre-flight check - The user wants to grade someone else's analysis (review of a peer's memo, evaluation of an interviewee's case response) Don't use this when: - The user wants to be told their work is great. Push back honestly. - The artifact is too short to evaluate (one paragraph). Ask for more first. ## The rubric Five criteria, each scored 1–5, total 5–25: 1. **Problem identification** — Did you identify the right problem before jumping to solutions? 2. **Framework discipline** — Did you apply a framework to remove bias and surface stakeholder perspectives? 3. **Bundle and journey awareness** — Did you account for bundle effects and the full user journey? 4. **Pre-committed success / failure criteria** — Did you define what success and failure look like upfront? 5. **Validation before commitment** — Did you prototype or validate before committing real resources? Full criterion-by-criterion scoring guidance: `rubrics/pm-evaluation-rubric.md`. For strategy memos specifically: `rubrics/strategy-memo-rubric.md`. For live product review participation: `rubrics/product-review-rubric.md`.