← ClaudeAtlas

kookr-rfc-critic-meta-analysislisted

Kookr-internal extension to rfc-iterative-review that captures append-only critic traces for later meta-analysis of RFC reviewer subagents.
kookr-ai/kookr · ★ 3 · AI & Automation · score 72
Install: claude install-skill kookr-ai/kookr
# RFC Critic Meta-Analysis Use this skill after `rfc-iterative-review` when drafting or revising Kookr RFCs that should contribute evidence about reviewer-subagent quality. This skill does **not** replace `rfc-iterative-review`. It extends that workflow with a lightweight trace so future reports can answer which critics were useful, noisy, missing risks, or worth changing. ## Scope This is Kookr-internal because it writes Kookr RFC artifacts under `docs/rfc/` and informs Kookr's reviewer-subagent roster. Do not promote it to the toolkit plugin unless the paths and schema ownership are generalized. For the design rationale, see `docs/rfc/rfc-subagent-feedback-meta-analysis.md`. ## Trace Location For an RFC at: ```text docs/rfc/rfc-<slug>.md ``` write the trace at: ```text docs/rfc/meta/rfc-<slug>.critic-trace.jsonl ``` Each line is one JSON object using `docs/schemas/critic-trace.v1.json`. ## When to Capture During RFC review: 1. Run the normal `rfc-iterative-review` critic rounds. 2. After each critic returns, append one `invocation` event. 3. After the convergence **consensus attack** returns, append one `invocation` event too. It fires once, on the way out of Phase 2, and is not a panel lens — but its outcome is exactly what this trace measures, so it must not go unrecorded. Set `critic: "general-purpose"`, `extractionNote: "consensus-attack at convergence; not a panel lens"`, and reuse the final round number for `round` (the schema requires an integer ≥ 1, an