← ClaudeAtlas

oracle-challengelisted

Challenge an approach with critical thinking. Use when questioning assumptions, validating decisions, testing approach validity, or preventing automatic agreement.
martinffx/atelier · ★ 27 · AI & Automation · score 85
Install: claude install-skill martinffx/atelier
# Challenge: Critical Thinking Prompt ## Step 1: Parse Challenge Request <strategist> @agent-oracle Analyze the challenge request: $ARGUMENTS **Challenge Extraction:** - **Core concern**: Extract the main doubt or question - **Target approach**: Identify what is being challenged - **Context**: Relevant background from current session - **Specific aspects**: Particular elements to question **Challenge Summary:** You're challenging: [identified approach] Because: [extracted concern] In context of: [session context] </strategist> ## Step 2: Set Up Critical Thinking Framework <framework> **What to Question:** - **Underlying assumptions**: What beliefs support this approach? - **Evidence base**: What data or experience validates it? - **Context fit**: How well does it work in your specific situation? - **Alternatives considered**: What other options were explored? - **Risk factors**: What could go wrong with this approach? **Critical Thinking Prompts:** - Is this approach solving the right problem? - Are the underlying assumptions still valid? - What evidence contradicts this direction? - How does this fit with your constraints and goals? - What are the opportunity costs? </framework> ## Step 3: Sequential Thinking Analysis <strategist> @agent-oracle Use sequential thinking (mcp__sequential-thinking__sequentialthinking) to analyze this challenge: **Thought 1**: Question the fundamental assumptions **Thought 2**: Examine contradictory evidence **Thought 3**: Explore alt