chart-honestylisted
Install: claude install-skill raghuramsirigiri/raghuram-skills
# Chart honesty
A column chart whose axis starts well above zero can draw a 7% rise as a bar twice as tall.
Nobody lied in a number, and the audience still leaves with the wrong size of change. This skill
reviews each chart a deck already has and says, for each one, whether it misleads, how,
by how much, and the fix.
**The product is the settings.** Anyone can say "that chart looks off". Saying *the axis is
set to start at 50, so the tallest bar is drawn 1.9× the shortest for an 11% difference*,
from the chart's own XML, is what gets a chart fixed rather than argued about. **Its twin is
restraint:** a line chart with a non-zero axis is fine, a picture can't be checked, and a
clean chart is reported as clean.
## Workflow
### 1. Take the charts as given
A `.pptx` / `.potx` path, or charts described in chat (type, categories, values, axis range,
title, units). Read every slide once: each native chart's XML, the slide title and text,
and the speaker notes. Number slides `S1…Sn` in deck order.
Read `references/checks.md` §1 before extracting. It says what to read from the chart XML
(plot type, `min`/`max`, value axes in use, number formats, axis titles), that **notes are
never visible**, and that **a picture of a chart carries no data**: never estimate values,
axis ranges or slice sizes from pixels.
**Ask nothing unless genuinely blocked.** One question, and only this one:
- No deck and no chart described → *"Send the deck (or describe the charts) and I'll check them."*
A