← ClaudeAtlas

examples-are-not-requirementslisted

Treats user examples as illustrations of a category, not a complete list: identify the category, then add relevant items the user did not mention. Start by restating in one sentence which categories the examples point to, then work at that level instead of letting the examples take over the answer; label the user examples separately, and add what they would not think of on their own, without filler. If the examples are things the user really plans to do, answer each concretely first, then add a separate section. Triggers include: "for example", "for instance", "e.g.", "such as", "things like", "like" (when it introduces examples), "比如", "比如说", "例如", "举个例子", "打个比方", "像……这种". Also use when one named thing clearly stands for a whole category, even without marker words. Do NOT use when the user gives an explicit closed list ("just these", "only these", "do exactly this"), when they give no examples at all, or when the examples show a format or style to copy rather than content to expand.
reshiramsq18-alt/examples-are-not-requirements · ★ 12 · AI & Automation · score 79
Install: claude install-skill reshiramsq18-alt/examples-are-not-requirements
# Examples Are Not Requirements ## What this skill does When users give examples, they usually aren't asking you to do exactly those things. They're showing you what *kind* of thing they want. This skill's job: when you see examples, don't rush to act on them. First say in one sentence which categories they point to, then work at that level: find other members of those categories the user didn't mention, and include those too. Don't let the examples take over the answer. ## How to tell: example or requirement Look at the user's wording. Signals that it is an example (illustrating a type): - 比如、比如说、例如、举个例子、打个比方、像……这种 - for example, for instance, e.g., such as, things like, like - A sentence like "things I can do now, like writing a plan or making a budget" — they are naming a category by giving two members of it. - A single named thing with no marker words, when the context shows it stands for a type. If nothing in the message shows that, treat it as the user's chosen target (see Case 1 and Case 4 in `cases.md`). But if the user names one specific thing as the actual target ("fix this file", "book this flight"), that is a requirement, not an example. Signals that it is a requirement (do exactly this): - 就要、必须是、就做这个、照做、就要这几个、别的不用 - do exactly this, just this, only these, nothing else Default: if the user used "for example", "such as", "比如", "例如", or an equivalent marker, treat it as an example, not a requirement. ## When the examples are real plans Sometimes the exa