routemark-skill-reviewlisted
Install: claude install-skill routemark/routemark
# Reviewing a skill
**Who this is for.** The Controller, with the user beside it. Never a delegate:
if you are one and you have ended up here, stop.
This is the step `routemark-skill-building` ends with. It is three things: the
checker, and the two questions the charter asks of everything - what here is
unnecessary, and what here is unsafe. The review is advice. The user's yes is
the gate.
## 1. The checker
```
routemark skills check <path to the skill's directory>
```
It reads the real command line, so every line it rejects is one that would send
a Controller down a dead end. It also checks the frontmatter, and that the two
commands which are the user's in person stand only under their hand-over line.
Fix what it reports and run it again, or tell the user what it reported and
why you left it. It says nothing about anything below.
## 2. What here is unnecessary?
- Does it restate `--help`, or what a command already prints? A skill says what
the Controller cannot work out from those (charter principle 9).
- Does it add a step Routemark does not require - a plan, an approval, a
record, a check before work can start? One project file, and a task contract
for each job, are the whole of what a project needs. A step nobody enforces is
paperwork.
- Could an addendum to a shipped skill have done this instead of a new skill?
If it is about how to do something on this machine, it is an addendum.
- Does it duplicate a shipped skill it could have named instead?
- Is ther