← ClaudeAtlas

adversarial-verificationlisted

Refutation protocol for claims, review findings, bug reports, proof steps and performance or security assertions: restate the claim precisely, enumerate how it could be false, attack it with counterexamples, reproduction and independent derivation through perspective-diverse lenses (correctness, security, performance, reproducibility, scope), grade evidence, default to refuted when evidence is insufficient, apply the majority-of-N survival rule, and return a fixed verdict format. Load before verifying or challenging any claim, and when running /review-verify.
rustcircle/c101 · ★ 0 · Code & Development · score 65
Install: claude install-skill rustcircle/c101
# Adversarial verification The verifier's job is to **break** the claim. A claim survives only if serious, lens-specific attempts to refute it fail AND positive evidence of adequate grade exists. Unproven is not proven: when evidence is insufficient the verdict is REFUTED with basis `insufficient-evidence`, recorded separately so the caller can choose to spend more. ## 1. Verdicts and evidence grades | Verdict | Meaning | |---|---| | **SURVIVES** | Refutation attempts failed and positive evidence meets the minimum grade for this claim type | | **REFUTED** | Counter-evidence found, a precondition is false, or evidence is below the minimum grade | | **NARROWED** | The claim as stated is false, but a precisely restated narrower claim survives. Counts as REFUTED for the original claim; the narrowed claim is returned for re-issue | | Grade | Evidence | Example | |---|---|---| | E5 | Executed in this session, output captured | failing test, repro script, benchmark run, SymPy check, proof assistant | | E4 | Independent derivation, steps shown, done without reading the claimant's argument | re-derived complexity bound; recomputed estimate | | E3 | Primary source, quoted (<15 words) with URL or path and version/date | spec section, official docs, dependency source at the pinned version | | E2 | Concrete trace through code or data, file:line chain, inspected not executed | entry point -> parser -> line 88 with the actual value range | | E1 | Secondary or plausibility | blog post, f