← ClaudeAtlas

delphi-methodlisted

Run Delphi panels with agents: question framing, panel design for low error correlation, anonymous round-1 estimates with rationale, controlled feedback (median, IQR, clustered arguments, outlier rationales), revision rules against herding, consensus and stability criteria with exact thresholds, persistent-dissent and crux handling, aggregation, and the consensus report. Load when several agents must converge on an estimate, forecast, probability, ranking or judgment.
rustcircle/c101 · ★ 0 · AI & Automation · score 65
Install: claude install-skill rustcircle/c101
# Delphi method for agent panels Delphi (RAND, Dalkey and Helmer, 1950s-60s) has four defining features: **anonymity**, **iteration**, **controlled feedback**, and **statistical aggregation** of the final round. It outperforms unstructured groups mainly by removing social pressure and by letting sound minority arguments travel without their authors' status (Rowe and Wright, 1999, review the evidence). Agent panels add two risks human panels have less of, and this skill is built around them: 1. **Correlated errors.** Panelists on the same model with the same framing make the same mistakes; seven of them are worth much less than seven independent opinions. 2. **Conformity convergence.** LLM panelists move toward the shown median without new reasons. Convergence then measures compliance, not knowledge. ## 0. Does Delphi fit? | Situation | Use | |---|---| | One quantity, probability, ranking or rating; judgment needed; no cheap ground truth | Delphi (this skill) | | The answer can be computed, measured or looked up | do that instead (tester, Bash, fact-checker) | | Several complete competing solutions | mediator-voting (`mediate` workflow, main thread only) | | A single decision to attack from both sides | structured-debate | | Complementary partial reports | expert-synthesis | | You already have the estimates and only need to pool them | bayesian-aggregation | ## 1. Frame the question (most panels fail here) Write a question spec before recruiting anyone: ```yaml qu