manuscript-reviewlisted
Install: claude install-skill ryan-ressmeyer/llm-skills
# Manuscript Review
## Overview
Collect critiques of a manuscript from multiple sources and levels, synthesize them into a prioritized revision plan, and either save the plan for later execution or hand off to `manuscript-editing` in the same session. This skill handles critique and planning only — it does not edit the manuscript.
## When to Use
- Reviewing a manuscript draft before submission
- Systematic critique of a paper, grant, or long-form document
- User wants structured feedback on a piece of writing
- User has external reviews (journal comments, collaborator feedback) to synthesize into a plan
- User wants to plan revisions before executing them
## Process Flow
```dot
digraph manuscript_review {
rankdir=TB;
node [shape=box];
start [label="Read manuscript\nCheck for existing reviews/"];
existing [shape=diamond, label="Existing\nreviews?"];
ask_resume [label="Ask user:\npick up or start fresh?"];
recommend [label="Recommend critique level\n(structural, line, copy)\nor ingest existing"];
user_confirm [shape=diamond, label="User selects\ncritique approach"];
structural [label="STRUCTURAL\nInvoke reverse-outline"];
line [label="LINE\nPropose section divisions\nDispatch section-critique"];
copy [label="COPY\nInvoke copy-review"];
ingest [label="INGEST\nRead user-provided\ncritiques/reviews"];
more [shape=diamond, label="More critique\nneeded?"];
triage [label="Invoke critique-triage\non all collected critiques"]