← ClaudeAtlas

model-committeelisted

Run one consequential, contestable decision through a deliberative committee of GPT-5.6 and Claude Opus 5, chaired by opus (default), fable, or sol. Not for factual lookups, brainstorming, routine implementation, independent-coder reliability, or final professional judgment. Use when several options are defensible and the two model families should propose, critique, revise, and cross-rank under a predeclared rubric.
scdenney/open-science-skills · ★ 53 · AI & Automation · score 74
Install: claude install-skill scdenney/open-science-skills
# Model Committee Run a GPT-5.6 member and a Claude Opus 5 member as a deliberating committee, then chair the result. Keep the line to `$model-council-voting` sharp: a council measures independent disagreement, while this committee deliberately exposes each member to the other's argument and returns one decision. Read [`references/protocol.md`](references/protocol.md) completely before running a committee. It carries the use-case gate, the brief template, the three round contracts, the decision rule, and the `decision.md` schema. ## Pick the chair One skill, three chairs. The chair is a parameter, not a separate skill — the former `$model-committee-fable` and `$model-committee-sol` are now the `fable` and `sol` rows below. The protocol, the drivers, and all three rounds are identical whichever chair runs, with exactly one exception the table states: under a Sol chair the GPT member drops to Terra. Ask the user which chair they want if they did not say; default to `opus`. | chair | GPT member | Claude member | Chair pin | Why this chair | |---|---|---|---|---| | `opus` (default) | `gpt-5.6-sol`, effort `xhigh` | `claude-opus-5`, effort `high` | the running session, or `claude-opus-5` at effort `high` | Strongest available synthesis. Shares a family with the Opus member, which is exactly why it must not vote a third time. | | `fable` | `gpt-5.6-sol`, effort `xhigh` | `claude-opus-5`, effort `high` | `claude-fable-5`, effort `max`, through `claude-member.sh` | The heavy rea