← ClaudeAtlas

review-designlisted

Review design, implementation, and task documents produced by design. Evaluates document quality, internal consistency, and technical soundness. Use after design completes and before starting implement.
serpro69/claude-toolbox · ★ 144 · Code & Development · score 73
Install: claude install-skill serpro69/claude-toolbox
<!-- codex: tool-name mapping applied. See .codex/scripts/session-start.sh --> # Design Review ## Conventions Read capy knowledge base conventions at [shared-capy-knowledge-protocol.md](shared-capy-knowledge-protocol.md). ## Overview Pre-implementation review gate that evaluates design documents produced by `$kk:design` before code is written. Sits between `$kk:design` (creates docs) and `$kk:implement` (executes them). Reviews tree distinct dimensions - document quality/structure (completeness, internal consistency, clarity, convention adherence) - technical soundness (architectural viability, edge cases, failure modes, trade-off analysis) - feature value (Does the feature improve things for end-users? Is it useful? Is it correct in _how_ it tries to solve the problem?) ## Review Modes ### Standard Mode (`$kk:review-design`) Reviews design documents in the main conversation context. Fast, single-pass review using the workflow below. ### Isolated Mode (`$kk:review-design:isolated`) Delegates detection to independent reviewers that did not participate in the design, then annotates their findings with author context. Two parallel reviewers: a `design-reviewer` sub-agent and `pal codereview` (external model in native format). Produces a report organized by agreement level with corroborated findings highlighted. - **Cost**: Higher (sub-agent + external model + annotation) - **Isolation**: True — reviewers have zero authorship bias or session context - **Degradation**: