review-speclisted
Install: claude install-skill serpro69/claude-toolbox
<!-- codex: tool-name mapping applied. See .codex/scripts/session-start.sh -->
# Implementation Review
## Conventions
Read capy knowledge base conventions at [shared-capy-knowledge-protocol.md](shared-capy-knowledge-protocol.md).
**Profile detection.** See [shared-profile-detection.md](shared-profile-detection.md) for the shared detection procedure. When an active profile populates a `review-spec/` phase slot, its `index.md` content is loaded before per-task verification begins.
## Overview
Systematically compare implemented code against a feature's `design.md`, `implementation.md`, and `tasks.md` in `/docs/wip/[feature]/`. Works both mid-implementation (reviewing completed tasks only) and post-implementation (full feature review).
Findings go in **both directions** — code that deviates from spec AND spec that is wrong or outdated given the code.
## Required Outputs
Before declaring the review complete, verify all outputs are delivered:
- [ ] Review report presented to user
- [ ] User-confirmed intentional `SPEC_DEV`/`EXTRA_IMPL` findings indexed as `kk:arch-decisions` (skip if none confirmed)
- [ ] Next steps confirmation from user
Indexing is owned by this skill — callers (e.g., `$kk:implement`) do NOT duplicate it.
## Review Modes
### Standard Mode (`$kk:review-spec`)
Reviews spec conformance in the main conversation context. Single-pass review using the workflow below.
### Isolated Mode (`$kk:review-spec:isolated`)
Delegates detection to an independent `sp