← ClaudeAtlas

codex-reviewlisted

Cross-model second opinion from the OpenAI Codex CLI (a different model family), read-only, in two seams — (1) code review of the current diff; (2) plan-stage premise challenge of a design packet (refute / missing / alternative, never a design). Opt-in only — use ONLY when the user explicitly asks with "codex review", "cross-model review", "second opinion on this diff", "別モデルでレビュー", "プランを Codex に反証させて", "前提を別モデルで叩いて", or invokes /codex-review or /codex-review --plan <file>. NOT a default step of the implementation chain (自発発火しない), NOT for letting Codex write code or design (read-only, divergence only), and NOT a replacement for the in-Claude reviewers.
shimo4228/claude-harness · ★ 2 · AI & Automation · score 78
Install: claude install-skill shimo4228/claude-harness
# Codex Review — Cross-Model Second Opinion A thin, read-only wrapper around `codex review` (OpenAI Codex CLI). It adds **one cross-model seam** to the review chain: a *different model family* reviews the diff, so it catches blind spots that an author and a same-model reviewer share. Grounded in [ADR-0013](../../docs/adr/0013-cross-model-review-seam-via-codex.md): this is a **decorrelation** seam, not a throughput tool. Use Claude's own sub-agents / Workflow for parallel throughput; use this only where a second *model* adds judgment Claude structurally can't add alone. ## When to Use **Opt-in のみ**(ADR-0055 — implementation chain の既定ステップではない)。 発火はユーザーの明示要求、または writing orchestrator skill が panel member として 明示的に配線している場合(readme-writer 等 — writing chain は ADR-0055 の対象外)だけ: - The user asks for a second opinion from a non-Claude model on a diff ("codex review", "別モデルでレビュー", /codex-review). - The user asks for a plan-stage premise challenge ("プランを Codex に反証させて", /codex-review --plan). - High-stakes **prose** diffs when the user asks for a cross-model pass before publishing/deposit. Use **prompt-driven mode** with writing-focused instructions; scoped modes run Codex's built-in code-review instructions, which fit prose poorly. Never self-trigger as part of the implementation chain. Skip it when Codex is not authenticated (the script fails fast — fall back to the Claude reviewers). ## Execution ``` bash ~/.claude/skills/codex-review/codex-review.sh $ARGUMENTS ``` Mode