← ClaudeAtlas

report-skill-failurelisted

Draft a compliant upstream bug report when a skill from Matt Pocock's skills repo (mattpocock/skills: tdd, diagnosing-bugs, grill-with-docs, to-spec, to-tickets, implement, code-review, and the rest) does the wrong thing in a real session. Use when the user corrects or interrupts the agent because it followed a mattpocock skill badly, when a skill's instructions were ambiguous, contradictory or unsafe and led the agent astray, or when the user says "report this skill", "file this upstream", or "that skill is broken".
simbaTmotsi/simba-skills · ★ 2 · Data & Documents · score 75
Install: claude install-skill simbaTmotsi/simba-skills
# Report a skill failure upstream The mattpocock/skills repo (https://github.com/mattpocock/skills) only accepts issues that describe an **observed failure in a real session**. Pull requests are collaborators-only and new-skill proposals are closed. This skill turns a failure into one short, compliant issue draft, and **never posts without the user's explicit yes**. ## 1. Decide whether it qualifies Stop and tell the user it doesn't qualify (and why) if any of these hold: - The failure came from the project, its agent instructions file (`CLAUDE.md`, `AGENTS.md`), or the user's request, not from the skill's text. - It is a wish ("it would be better if..."), a config option, a harness-specific branch, or a tweak for one workflow. Those belong in the project's own instructions or a project skill. - The skill lives in `misc/` (frozen) or it's a request for a new skill. - It matches a file in the repo's `.out-of-scope/` folder. Read them: `gh api repos/mattpocock/skills/contents/.out-of-scope --jq '.[].name'`, then fetch any that look related. - It's a harness built-in with the same name (for example Claude Code's own `/code-review`) rather than the mattpocock skill. Check which one actually loaded. One problem per issue. Several failures from one session are several drafts, or none. ## 2. Check it is not already fixed or filed - Read the current upstream `SKILL.md` (`gh api repos/mattpocock/skills/contents/skills/<bucket>/<skill>/SKILL.md --jq .content | base64 -d`). If ma