rootcause-reviewlisted

# Root Cause Review Skill ## Trigger This skill is invoked when the user runs `/rootcause-review` followed by a path to a rootcause_analysis.md file. Example: `/rootcause-review todos/rootcause_analysis.md` ## Purpose Perform rigorous scientific peer review of a root cause analysis document. This skill independently verifies all claims, tests all evidence, and appends a comprehensive review section to the original document. The goal is to validate or invalidate findings with the same scientific rigor applied to peer-reviewed research. **Critical Rule**: NEVER modify existing content in the analysis file. Only APPEND the review section at the end. ## Inputs - **Analysis file path** (required): Path to the rootcause_analysis.md file to review - The analysis file should contain: - Summary of the problem and claimed root cause - 5-whys analysis with evidence claims - Code references (file:line) - Evidence table with sources - Proposed solution ## Outputs - **Updated rootcause_analysis.md**: Original content PRESERVED, with review section APPENDED - Review section includes: - Validation status for each claim - Independent verification results - Confidence assessment - Gaps or errors identified - Final verdict ## Review Principles ### Scientific Rigor Standards 1. **Independent Verification**: Don't trust claims - verify them yourself 2. **Reproducibility**: Can you reproduce the same findings from the evidence? 3. **Falsifiability**: Actively try t