← ClaudeAtlas

scholastic-disputationlisted

Use when a choice between two or more named options is owed — "X or Y?", "which should we use?", "we need to pick one" — including when their success criteria are still vague. Also use when adjudicating conflicting reports or recommendations, when your own recommendation is challenged or overruled, when writing up a decision that will be defended later, or when you are about to give a verdict without having stated the losing case.
sudeepgupta90/foundational-thinking · ★ 0 · AI & Automation · score 70
Install: claude install-skill sudeepgupta90/foundational-thinking
# Scholastic Disputation ## Overview A determination is only worth as much as the case it defeated. State the opposing case in its strongest form **first**, then decide. The order is the method. Advocacy gives a verdict with no losing case. Deferral gives neither. ## The output contract When you determine a contested question, your answer contains these parts, in this order: 1. **The question, as a yes/no or an A-or-B.** If it will not take that form, it is not ready to be decided — the terms are still equivocal. 2. **Two or three objections** — the strongest cases against the answer you will give, each stated as its holder would state it, in their terms, with no built-in wince. If its holder would not recognise it as their argument, you have written the wrong objection. 3. **The one consideration that decides it** — the fact, measurement, or constraint the objections do not account for. 4. **Your determination**, and the **distinction** it rests on if there is one: the term that was doing two jobs, true in one sense and false in the other. 5. **A separate reply to each objection**, each opening with its declared move: - **Concede** — it holds, and I accept the cost - **Deny** — it fails, and here is the premise I reject - **Distinguish** — true in this sense, false in that one The label is the ruling. A paragraph that performs the move without naming it leaves the reader to work out which one you made, which is the part they needed. "As explain