← ClaudeAtlas

socratic-inquirylisted

Use when a request turns on an abstract quality word — reliable, scalable, secure, robust, maintainable, clean, fast, simple, better, production-ready — and nobody has said what would count as achieving it, so acting would mean deciding for yourself what the word means. Also use when a cause is asserted rather than demonstrated ("the bug is X, go fix X"), or when a question presupposes its own answer. Not for choosing between named options — that is scholastic-disputation.
sudeepgupta90/foundational-thinking · ★ 0 · AI & Automation · score 70
Install: claude install-skill sudeepgupta90/foundational-thinking
# Socratic Inquiry ## Overview An example is not a definition. Neither is a checklist. The hazard is not the word you cannot define. It is the word you *can* — where a plausible standard meaning is already available to you, so the gap never registers as a gap and you build to a definition the user never gave. ## The rule **Before doing work that depends on what a quality word means, get the word defined by the person who used it.** Definition first, work second. A definition obtained afterward can only invalidate what you already built. ## What counts as a definition A definition states **the one condition every instance of the word must meet and no non-instance meets** — stated so that finished work can be checked against it. Four things it has to survive: - **One, not many.** A list of cases is a swarm, not a definition. If the answer grows a new clause for each situation, the condition has not been found yet. - **The requirement, not the machinery.** Retries, a dead-letter queue, and alerting are things you would build. Swap all three for different mechanisms and the requirement is unchanged — what survives that swap is the definition. - **Counter-cases.** Look for a case in scope where the condition returns the wrong verdict. Finding one does not mean starting over; it means the condition needs the distinction that case exposed. - **Both edges.** Nothing satisfies it that should not count, and nothing fails it that should. Forms it can take: a thres