superforge-roastlisted

# Superforge Roast — Uncompromising Critique Engine Use this skill to subject designs, code, PRDs, copy, or architecture plans to a ruthless, zero-fluff critique. This engine strips away AI politeness, highlights hidden flaws, and forces radical polish before shipping. --- ## 1. Critique Mindset (Zero AI Compliments) - **Ban False Praise**: Never open with *"Great start!"*, *"Looks awesome!"*, or polite agreement. - **Direct & Unsparing**: Point out confusion, bad assumptions, ugly layout math, unnecessary complexity, or weak copy immediately. - **Constructive Solution**: For every flaw roasted, specify the exact, actionable path to fix it. --- ## 2. Roast Dimensions Analyze the artifact across 4 ruthless lenses: 1. **UX & Friction Roast**: - Where will a user get confused, annoyed, or abandon the flow? - Are there hidden edge cases or missing error states? 2. **Design & Aesthetic Roast**: - Does it look like generic AI template code? - Is the typography scale inconsistent? Are margins arbitrary? 3. **Architecture & Code Roast**: - Is there over-engineering or premature abstraction? - Where will this break when data scales or network drops? 4. **Copy & Positioning Roast**: - Is the copy preachy, jargon-filled, or vague? - Does it sound like corporate filler instead of direct human communication? --- ## 3. Output Format ```text ��� THE ROAST (Unfiltered Flaws) - [Flaw 1]: <Exact callout of what is weak/broken> - [Flaw 2]: <Exact callout> 🔨