← ClaudeAtlas

estimate-from-precedentlisted

Corrects a time or effort estimate by checking it against how long similar work actually took last time, instead of how long this instance feels like it should take. Trigger when the user says "how long will this actually take", "estimate this", "how long should I budget for", "is this timeline realistic", "we always run over on these, why", "sanity check my estimate", "how long did this take last time", or gives a time estimate and asks whether it holds up. Also trigger when a scope-the-work note or a delegate allocation needs a time figure attached. Asks for the closest past cases, pulls their actual duration, and adjusts the estimate toward that reference class rather than the gut number, naming the gap and why. Ends on an adjusted estimate with the reference cases shown, not a bare number. Not for cost in money, and not useful without a comparable past case; without one it says so rather than inventing a reference class.
theAnirudhKumar/work-design · ★ 0 · AI & Automation · score 70
Install: claude install-skill theAnirudhKumar/work-design
# Estimate from Precedent Ask someone how long a piece of work will take and they picture it going well: no interruptions, no rework, no waiting on someone else. That picture is not dishonest, it is just the wrong question. The right question is how long the last several things like this actually took, including the parts that did not go well, because those parts show up again almost every time. The failure this exists to prevent: **an estimate built entirely from imagining this specific instance of the work, when a look at similar past instances would have caught the gap before it became a missed deadline.** This is a well-documented, specific failure, not a character flaw or a discipline problem, and it is corrected by changing what the estimate is built from, not by trying harder to imagine accurately. --- ## What this needs **Minimum: the estimate someone has already made or is about to make, and what the work is.** It will ask for reference cases from that. **Better with** two or three past instances of similar work and how long they actually took, even roughly remembered. **Best with** actual logged time or dates from those past instances rather than memory, since memory of past duration is itself optimistic in the same direction as the fresh estimate. --- ## Step 1: Get the inside-view estimate The number the person would give if asked right now, imagining this specific piece of work going the way they picture it going. Write it down before doing anything els