← ClaudeAtlas

media-judgelisted

Judge a finished AI-made video, image or track by measuring it, then rank takes on the defects found. One command reads every frame and writes facts with timestamps and evidence: broken frames, banding after a simulated X or YouTube upload, numbers that jiggle, spelling, too much on screen, nothing leading the eye, motion with no cause, pinned graphics, sliding labels, a face, outfit or light that changed, sound after the cut, loudness, voice against the script, and distance to references against the template. A fresh agent settles only what eyes can settle. No score out of 10. Use when someone says "review this video", "check my render", "self-review", "QA", "judge", "critique", "score these takes", "pick the best take", "does it match the reference", "it looks like a template", "is it ready to post", "reverse engineer this reel", or after any agent finishes a film, short drama, reel or ad. Not for making or repairing media (varg-ai, varg-video-editing) or ad law (ai-ad-compliance-check).
vargHQ/skills · ★ 38 · AI & Automation · score 86
Install: claude install-skill vargHQ/skills
# Media judge > Step 9 of 10 in [How to make a video with an AI agent in ten steps](https://varg.ai/how-to/make-a-video-in-ten-steps). The full guide, with every test and source: https://varg.ai/how-to/judge-an-ai-video-without-bias (as Markdown: add `.md`). **Measure, don't grade.** A judgment here is a time, a number and a picture. "Looks great", "8/10" and "feels premium" are not findings, and neither is any adjective with no measurement behind it. Code finds the moment and a fresh pair of eyes reads only that moment, in that order, because the other way round fails: 12 vision models scored at most 54.1% on spotting temporal glitches; Claude Opus caught 17.5% of them, Gemini 3 Flash said "glitch" to about 87% of clean clips ([TempGlitch](https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.21443), gameplay clips). Uniform sampling at 0.5 fps caught 11.81% of faults under 0.2 s ([SynFlash](https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.17374)), and GPT-4 preferred its own output 0.705 and 0.912 of the time on tasks where people saw equal quality ([Panickssery et al.](https://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13076)). So: 1. **Facts:** `judge.py` reads every frame and every sample. It does not sample. 2. **Eyes:** a fresh agent opens only the evidence and answers narrow questions. 3. **Verdict:** counted defects. Ranking follows from the counts, never from a feeling. **What this has been tested on.** Planted defects in footage it never saw while being tuned: 18 of 22 caught, 6 of 8 clean controls (25 of 25 and 10 of 10 on the foo