← ClaudeAtlas

vogonlisted

Use when the user wants a critique, second opinion, devil's advocate or skeptical review of a plan, design doc, proposal, decision, commit, diff, documentation or work in progress; asks "what's wrong with this", to "poke holes in", "tear apart" or "sanity-check" it; asks to score, rate or grade it; asks "is this ready", "can I merge / ship this" or wants an approve-or-block verdict; asks "are the docs still right", "do the comments match the code", "what edge cases did I miss" or "check the error handling" about existing work; asks to fix something "until it passes"; or mentions vogon ("vogon this", "run vogon on"). Not for routine edits, explaining code, or a review the user asked to do with another named tool.
vjfrosty/vogon · ★ 1 · Code & Development · score 77
Install: claude install-skill vjfrosty/vogon
# Vogon A fresh critic reviews the target without this conversation's reasoning; you verify its findings, score the target 1–10 and save a ledger. **Arguments:** `$ARGUMENTS` ## Modes, lenses and words Take the words from the arguments, or from the user's sentence. One mode, any lenses, then the target; nothing matches → review. | Word | Also | Plain phrases | What happens | |---|---|---|---| | *(none)* | `review` | "second opinion", "rate it", "is this ready" | steps 1–5 | | `stamp` | `gate`, `verdict`, `inspect`, `audit` | "can I merge this" | + APPROVED / DEMOLISHED (step 6) | | `ask` | `quick` | "quick take", "poke holes in" | critic's answer only (step 9) | | `fix` | | "fix it until it passes" | + fix loop (step 7) | | `fix auto` | | + "without asking" | loop without asking | | `recheck` | `again` | "did I fix it" | focused re-review (step 8) | | lens `papertrail` | `docs`, `comments` | "are the docs still right" | critic checks docs vs. code first | | lens `loopholes` | `edges`, `errors`, `holes` | "what edge cases did I miss" | critic checks failure paths first | A lens combines with any mode. Options: `focus:`, `settled:` (decisions not to raise), `model: session | opus | sonnet | haiku | fable` (default `session`: pass no `model`, so the critic uses this conversation's model). ## 0. Confirm when you started it yourself If the user's latest message starts with `/vogon` or names vogon, go on. Otherwise you chose this skill from their words: resolve the target (