← ClaudeAtlas

reviewsearchlisted

Search 200k+ ML/NLP/CV peer reviews (ICLR/ICML/NeurIPS/COLM) with their author rebuttals. Use when the user wants real examples of reviewer concerns, how a kind of paper gets critiqued, or how authors rebutted — e.g. "find reviews asking for significance tests", "how did papers rebut novelty concerns", "what weaknesses do reviewers raise about diffusion models".
yjoonjang/reviewsearch-skill · ★ 19 · Code & Development · score 61
Install: claude install-skill yjoonjang/reviewsearch-skill
# ReviewSearch Search a corpus of **205,988 peer reviews** (with author rebuttals) from ICLR / ICML / NeurIPS / COLM, served by the ReviewSearch hybrid-search API. ## When to use Reach for this when the user wants **real peer-review evidence**: what reviewers criticize about a kind of paper, examples of a specific concern, or how authors rebutted a critique. Not for searching paper *content* — this searches *reviews*. ## How to search Run the bundled script (Python 3, no dependencies). **Paths here are relative to this skill's own directory**, the one this SKILL.md was loaded from, so they resolve in any host that discovers skills: ```bash python "<this skill dir>/scripts/search_reviews.py" "<query>" [options] ``` Options: `--top-k N` (default 10), `--accepted-only`, `--year-min YYYY`, `--year-max YYYY` (corpus spans 2023–2026). Example: ```bash python "<this skill dir>/scripts/search_reviews.py" \ "reviews asking for a statistical significance test" --top-k 5 --accepted-only ``` ## Writing good queries - Queries are **English** and work best as **concern-style natural language**, e.g. "missing ablation on learning rate", "reviewers doubting reproducibility", "papers criticized for weak baselines". - The primary search target is each review's **concern** text (weaknesses + questions). ## Reading results The script prints JSON: `{ count, results: [...] }`. Each result has: - `venue`, `year`, `title`, `decision` (Accept/Reject variants) - `summary` — the revi