empirical-se-standardslisted
Install: claude install-skill ymurat/academic-agent-skills
# Empirical SE study design and review (ACM SIGSOFT Empirical Standards)
Rules: formal prose, no em dashes, tables for comparisons. Never invent citations, DOIs, sample sizes or statistics. Summarise the standards in your own words; quote only short phrases with attribution.
Local sources:
- `resources/empirical-se-standards/essential-attributes.md`: essential attribute checklists for all 19 standards, extracted from the repo on 2026-10-31. Read the relevant section before any check.
- `resources/empirical-se-standards/raw/*.md`: full standard files (desirable and extraordinary attributes, antipatterns, reviewer notes).
- `resources/empirical-se-standards/verified-refs.md`: verified citations.
## 1. The standards (repo master, last pushed 2026-10-26; no versioned releases, so cite with access date)
Every paper must meet the **General Standard** plus each method standard that applies.
| Standard | Use when | Key essential attributes (summary) |
|---|---|---|
| General | always | clear purpose and motivation; named, appropriate method; data collection and analysis described; results answer RQs; limitations, ethics, non-misleading visuals |
| Case Study and Ethnography | in-depth study of a real case | justified case selection, rich site description, case study type, unit of analysis, chain of evidence |
| Action Research | researcher intervenes in an organisation | researcher-host relation, interventions and how chosen and evaluated, cycles, longitudinal span, reactions, l