← ClaudeAtlas

analyze-sibling-paperlisted

Deep-analyze a specific related / competing / concurrent paper — reading the ACTUAL paper, not its abstract — to decide the "isn't this just X?" question before a reviewer asks it: what it really does, whether it's prior or concurrent work, the strongest scoop a reviewer could claim, whether your delta is REAL or merely cosmetic, and the exact cite + positioning clause (or a scoop escalation) to apply. Saves the analysis to the paper's research folder and surfaces action points. Use whenever a paper close enough to yours surfaces — via verify-citations' nearest-neighbor, a reviewer's "this was already done", your own lit search, or an arXiv alert. Distinct from verify-citations (confirms a cite is real + one-line delta) and study-accepted-papers (mines a venue's accepted corpus for levers); this one does the deep per-competitor overlap/scoop analysis. Compose with verify-citations (feeds it neighbors), harden-paper (its nearest-neighbor-scoop axis calls this), and extend-paper (a scooped angle can become the
zernie/paperlint · ★ 7 · Code & Development · score 74
Install: claude install-skill zernie/paperlint
<!-- vigiles:sha256:f528cbe9e892d6d0 compiled from skills/analyze-sibling-paper/SKILL.md.spec.ts --> # analyze-sibling-paper — settle "isn't this just X?" before a reviewer does ## Run me 🔴 FIRST, before any other step: ``` node .claude/skills/paper-pipeline/scripts/announce.mjs analyze-sibling-paper <paper-dir> ``` An advisory pass cannot be observed failing — silence is both its error state and its normal state — so starting is an event, and events get written down. The `<paper-dir>` argument is **your** paper, not the sibling — the row belongs to the paper being defended. The sibling is named by `<report-path>` when the verdict is recorded. When a paper close to yours surfaces, the wrong move is to cite it from its abstract and move on — that leaves a scoop risk you can't see and a reviewer can. This skill reads the *actual* competitor, judges whether your contribution genuinely differs, and produces a saved analysis with concrete action points (the exact positioning clause to add, or — if it's a real scoop — an escalation, not a clause). Grounding: the original-contribution criterion (a paper a reviewer thinks is a repackaging earns no authorship credit even if accepted). Composes with `verify-citations` (which surfaces the nearest neighbors) and `harden-paper` (whose scoop axis calls this). ## When it fires Any paper a reviewer could point at and say "this was already done." Triggers: a nearest-neighbor from `verify-citations`; a reviewer/panelist's "isn't this