← ClaudeAtlas

grade-paper-writinglisted

Use when asking "does this paper read well?" / "is the writing any good?" / "it reads like a wall of text and jargon" / "grade the writing" on a draft. Grades WRITING CRAFT only — nine dimensions 1–5 (Title, Abstract, Intro architecture, Structure, Prose clarity, Jargon discipline, Landing-the-point, Figure economy, Honesty-without-hedge-stacking) against how the best-written papers read (Peyton Jones, McEnerney, Gopen & Swan; exemplars Trusting Trust, Carlini, Greshake), naming the offending sentence and the fix for each. Runs the PERSONA cold-read stall pass (a committed non-academic persona subagent, per-section) whose stall inventory — not the rubric number — is the readability gate other skills consume (pc-panel-review, paper-adversarial-review, harden-paper). Defaults to a blind multi-grader panel; after fixes, mandates the claims-preservation diff (row `claims`). NOT a content/defect review (paper-adversarial-review / pc-panel-review), NOT a structural cut plan (tighten-paper — run that first on a bloa
zernie/paperlint · ★ 7 · Code & Development · score 74
Install: claude install-skill zernie/paperlint
<!-- vigiles:sha256:c0907d5c98e2c831 compiled from skills/grade-paper-writing/SKILL.md.spec.ts --> # grade-paper-writing — grade how the paper READS, then fix it sentence by sentence ## Run me 🔴 FIRST, before any other step: ``` node .claude/skills/paper-pipeline/scripts/announce.mjs grade-paper-writing <paper-dir> ``` An advisory pass cannot be observed failing — silence is both its error state and its normal state — so starting is an event, and events get written down. The review skills hunt scientific defects; `study-accepted-papers` checks whether the contribution clears the venue's bar. Neither tells you the paper is a slog to read. This skill does exactly that: it grades the **writing craft** against how the best-written papers actually read, and turns each low score into a concrete, sentence-level fix. Its target failure mode is the common one — *"a wall of text and jargon that doesn't drive home how crazy the situation is"* — which is a writing problem, not a science problem, and which the defect-hunting skills will pass right over. Grounding (do NOT re-derive — read it): `../paper-pipeline/references/writing-craft.md` holds the craft rules, the exemplar lessons, and the full nine-dimension rubric with 1/5 anchors. This skill applies it. ## The frame to hold while grading (from the reference) The papers that make a human care share three moves: **(1) open on a problem/assumption the reader already holds; (2) break it with the single most visceral concrete ins