← ClaudeAtlas

harden-paperlisted

Use when asking "is this paper actually ready to submit?" / "what's still missing before I upload?" / "run the pre-submission gate" on a DRAFTED paper. The multi-axis hardening orchestrator — it runs the review skills AND closes the axes they miss (structure via tighten-paper, threat-model + ethics/dual-use, reproducibility artifact, double-blind hygiene, page/word-fit, citability), and its verdict is a VECTOR of gates reported worst-gate-first — any failing gate (readability, structure, claims, citations, nearest-neighbor scoop, mechanical) caps "ready" regardless of a high accept-probability. NOT for grading how the prose reads (grade-paper-writing), a structural cut plan alone (tighten-paper), or a single hostile review (paper-adversarial-review) — this calls all of those and makes the submit/no-submit decision. Composes with pc-panel-review / verify-citations (it calls them) and submit-paper (downstream).
zernie/paperlint · ★ 7 · AI & Automation · score 74
Install: claude install-skill zernie/paperlint
<!-- vigiles:sha256:7fb5e8709eb4c363 compiled from skills/harden-paper/SKILL.md.spec.ts --> # harden-paper — the multi-axis pre-submit gate > **Which paper skill?** `paper-adversarial-review` / `pc-panel-review` (whose venue-fit mode covers the > CFP-fit score) = the *reviewer's-eye* axis (defects, fit, accept-prob). `verify-citations` = the > *citation* axis. > **`harden-paper` (here) = the orchestrator** that runs those AND closes the axes a reviewer-sim > doesn't systematically hit — the submission-readiness gate. Run it after the draft is written and > before `submit-paper`. It does not re-implement the sub-skills; it calls them and checks the rest. ## Run me 🔴 FIRST, before any other step: ``` node .claude/skills/paper-pipeline/scripts/announce.mjs harden-paper <paper-dir> ``` An advisory pass cannot be observed failing — silence is both its error state and its normal state — so starting is an event, and events get written down. **Principle:** a paper dies from any *one* unclosed axis. Reviewers only *read* — so every claim, number, and omission must survive on the page. Go axis by axis; for each, **find → fix → re-verify**, don't just list. Below, each axis says what to run / check and the specific traps that recur. > Axes 1–10 are **soundness** gates (get it accepted / avoid desk-reject). Axis 11 (**citability**) is > the *impact* gate — a correct-but-forgettable paper passes review and gets cited zero times. For a > body of work, citability is not optional po