← ClaudeAtlas

paper-adversarial-reviewlisted

Use when asking "red-team this paper" / "what would Reviewer 2 attack?" / "find the weaknesses before I submit" — ONE fast hostile-but-fair review of a paper draft. Surfaces overclaims, methodology holes, missing baselines/citations, novelty concerns, threats to validity, and desk-reject risks, with concrete fixes, led by a multi-axis 1–5 scorecard whose card composes into a pc-panel-review panel. NOT the multi-reviewer accept/reject decision (pc-panel-review), a writing grade (grade-paper-writing — this skill consumes its stall inventory rather than re-grading prose), or the full pre-submit gate (harden-paper). Especially for security and agentic-coding measurement papers.
zernie/paperlint · ★ 7 · Code & Development · score 74
Install: claude install-skill zernie/paperlint
<!-- vigiles:sha256:2da081a03ae7fee3 compiled from skills/paper-adversarial-review/SKILL.md.spec.ts --> # paper-adversarial-review — be the reviewer who wants to reject it > **Which review skill?** `paper-adversarial-review` (you are here) = one hostile reviewer, fast defect > hunt. `pc-panel-review` = the whole PC (N independent lenses incl. an artifact-runner) + a chair > meta-review — the real pre-submission GATE, run LAST; its **venue-fit mode** is the one-reviewer > CFP-fit score (formerly `venue-review-sim`). Reach for an atom (this, or venue-fit mode) for a quick > spot-check; run the panel for the decision. ## Run me 🔴 FIRST, before any other step: ``` node .claude/skills/paper-pipeline/scripts/announce.mjs paper-adversarial-review <paper-dir> ``` An advisory pass cannot be observed failing — silence is both its error state and its normal state — so starting is an event, and events get written down. Purpose: catch what a real peer reviewer will hit, while it's still fixable. Peer review is **read, not run** — reviewers judge the *text, figures, and reported numbers*, rarely execute code. So the paper must be self-contained and airtight on its face. This skill simulates the skeptical reviewer and returns an actionable critique. ## How to run it Prefer a **separate model as the reviewer** (e.g. Fable via a subagent) so it's not the author grading itself. Give the reviewer the full paper text (Read the `.tex`/`.md`/PDF) and the target venue + paper type (short/f