← ClaudeAtlas

pc-panel-reviewlisted

Use when asking "what would the program committee decide?" / "simulate the reviewers" / "what's this paper's accept probability?" on a drafted paper + artifact. Spawns N independent reviewers with DISTINCT lenses (one actually RUNS the artifact), then synthesizes a PC-chair meta-review into an accept/reject decision, a calibrated probability, and consensus must-fixes. Requires grade-paper-writing's persona stall inventory + tighten-paper's structural verdict as inputs (blocked until they exist — the panel cannot feel reader fatigue on its own). Also has a lightweight single-reviewer VENUE-FIT MODE for a quick CFP-fit spot-check. NOT a single fast defect hunt (paper-adversarial-review), a writing grade (grade-paper-writing), or the full pre-submit gate (harden-paper, which calls this) — this models the PC decision itself.
zernie/paperlint · ★ 7 · Code & Development · score 74
Install: claude install-skill zernie/paperlint
<!-- vigiles:sha256:9622701a349ea249 compiled from skills/pc-panel-review/SKILL.md.spec.ts --> # pc-panel-review — model the whole PC, not one reviewer > **Which review skill?** `paper-adversarial-review` = one hostile reviewer, fast defect hunt. > `pc-panel-review` (you are here) = the whole PC (N independent lenses incl. an artifact-runner) + a > chair meta-review — the real pre-submission GATE, run LAST. This skill also has a **Venue-fit mode** > (below): ONE reviewer scoring a named venue's CFP rubric to predict its accept/reject — the quick > single-lens spot-check (formerly the standalone `venue-review-sim` skill). Reach for Venue-fit mode or > `paper-adversarial-review` for a fast spot-check; run the full panel (this) for the decision. ## Run me 🔴 FIRST, before any other step: ``` node .claude/skills/paper-pipeline/scripts/announce.mjs pc-panel-review <paper-dir> ``` An advisory pass cannot be observed failing — silence is both its error state and its normal state — so starting is an event, and events get written down. The Venue-fit mode gives ONE reviewer's fit score; `paper-adversarial-review` gives ONE defect hunt. A real decision is made by **2–4 reviewers with different priorities + a meta-review** that weighs consensus over any single voice. This skill runs that. The payoff over a single review: a **must-fix is what ≥2 independent reviewers flag** — that filters real blockers from one reviewer's hobbyhorse — and at least one reviewer **executes the artifa