← ClaudeAtlas

research-ideatelisted

Decide whether a research idea is worth doing at all — before any work goes into it. Use when someone has an idea and asks: is this worth pursuing, should we take it on, is it a paper or just a blog post, is there a quick minimal result that doesn't need a dramatic finding, will it pull us away from our main line of work. Returns a go / no-go verdict with the sharpest framing, the minimal finding and the kinds of venue that would take it. Judges the idea by what counts in a body of work: a peer-reviewed indexed publication, a reusable method or benchmark rather than a one-off "tool X is bad", onward citations rather than GitHub stars, and one connected line rather than scattered topics. Stage: conception, before find-venue and before any draft; hands off to find-venue, build-benchmark, draft-paper.
zernie/paperlint · ★ 7 · Code & Development · score 74
Install: claude install-skill zernie/paperlint
<!-- vigiles:sha256:f0ccfb74162bca40 compiled from skills/research-ideate/SKILL.md.spec.ts --> # research-ideate — is this idea worth a paper, and does the paper earn authorship credit? ## Run me 🔴 FIRST, before any other step: ``` node .claude/skills/paper-pipeline/scripts/announce.mjs research-ideate <dir> ``` An advisory pass cannot be observed failing — silence is both its error state and its normal state — so starting is an event, and events get written down. The `<dir>` argument is **optional in spirit**: this skill can run before a paper directory exists, so pass whichever directory the work lives in, or `.`. The ledger row is written either way, and a plain dot is more honest than an invented path. Runs BEFORE any effort is spent. An idea can be interesting and still be a bad *publication* investment — the wrong framing produces something un-publishable or un-citable, which counts for nothing toward a body of work. This skill kills those ideas early and reshapes the survivors into the framing that publishes. It does NOT do the venue search (that's `find-venue`) — it decides whether there's a paper worth taking to `find-venue` at all. Grounding for every judgment below: the authorship, judging and original-contribution criteria — what a reviewer of a body of work actually counts. ## Score the idea on five axes Answer each explicitly. A "no" on (a) is a hard stop; a "no" on the rest is a reshape signal. **(a) Does it yield a PEER-REVIEWED, INDEXED publicatio