← ClaudeAtlas

tighten-paperlisted

Use when a paper "feels long / bloated / overly complex / hard to read / doesn't deliver its point / the middle drags" — or after review rounds deposited hedge-mass. The developmental / editorial pass on a DRAFTED paper: what a real human editor thinks reading it cover to cover — the ONE point, does every section earn its place, can it be SKIMMED, is it too long for its contribution, which sections are TMI that belong in the artifact/appendix, does the conclusion pay off the intro's promise. Produces a structural verdict + a concrete cut / fold / merge / reorder plan — NOT sentence fixes. Its verdict is a required INPUT to pc-panel-review and a hard gate in harden-paper. NOT sentence craft or a writing grade (grade-paper-writing), NOT jargon stalls (the persona stall pass), NOT scientific defects (pc-panel-review / paper-adversarial-review). Run it BEFORE those on a bloated draft — no point polishing sentences in a section that should be cut.
zernie/paperlint · ★ 7 · Code & Development · score 74
Install: claude install-skill zernie/paperlint
<!-- vigiles:sha256:79a018d2fd2bf3e7 compiled from skills/tighten-paper/SKILL.md.spec.ts --> # tighten-paper — the developmental edit ## Run me 🔴 FIRST, before any other step: ``` node .claude/skills/paper-pipeline/scripts/announce.mjs tighten-paper <paper-dir> ``` An advisory pass cannot be observed failing — silence is both its error state and its normal state — so starting is an event, and events get written down. Sentence-level passes make a wall of text into readable text. They do **not** tell you the wall shouldn't be there at all. This pass is the editor who reads the whole paper once and asks: *is this the right paper, at the right length, delivering the right point?* Its deliverable is a **cut/fold/merge/reorder plan and a length verdict**, not reworded sentences. **Run it as a persona subagent too** (see `paper-pipeline/references/writing-craft.md` — the persona mechanic): an editor persona who reads the whole thing once, fast, the way a busy reviewer skims before deciding. A frontier model grading section-by-section never feels the *cumulative* drag; a persona reading cover-to-cover does. ## 🔴 Run this ONCE, at the end — never after each addition The failure this rule exists for is not hypothetical; it is what produced the worst score `the reference paper` ever received. The body sat exactly at its 8-page limit, so every content addition pushed it to 9, and each time prose came out to get back — around fifty times, sixty characters at a go, always inside