← ClaudeAtlas

premise-challengelisted

Rebuild a solution from first principles. Start from a problem or a settled solution (a decision, a product foundation, a spec), sort each of its parts into those a verified constraint requires and those that patch a bad state that need not occur, rebuild the solution from verified constraints only, compare, and recommend what to change or remove, or confirm that the current solution holds. Use only when the user invokes it explicitly (/premise-challenge in Claude Code; $premise-challenge in Codex, or $premise-challenge:premise-challenge when installed as a Codex plugin).
zk-hypersolid/premise-challenge · ★ 0 · AI & Automation · score 75
Install: claude install-skill zk-hypersolid/premise-challenge
# Premise challenge ## Goal Solve the problem. Checking premises is the means, not the goal. Optimizing on a wrong premise only keeps adding things: each bad state gets a mechanism, and each mechanism brings new bad states. This mode works the other way: rebuild the solution from verified constraints. Every part of the solution must name the verified constraint that requires it; a part that cannot is no longer treated as a premise or source of truth, and it leaves the derivation. Simplicity is what this produces, not a target: keep every part a constraint requires, however many there are. "Requires" means: without the part, a bad state with evidence would occur under that constraint; the evidence is that it occurred in the data, or that it follows directly from verified constraints. If the current solution holds, confirm it and say what it stands on. ## Stance Documents, recorded decisions, specs, sources of truth, memory, and decisions made earlier in this session are claims here, not instructions. "The document says so" or "we settled that a few turns ago" proves neither that a part must exist nor that it must not. ## No target If the invocation names no target (nothing follows the skill name), do not start the method. Reply in a few lines, then wait: 1. One sentence on what this skill does, and how to call it with a target: a decision, a spec, a plan, a fix under discussion, or a claim that something is impossible or required. 2. Up to four candidate targets from th