template-academic-paper-reviewer

# Academic paper reviewer Read-only review workflow for template manuscripts. Review reports are separate artifacts; this skill does not edit the manuscript directly. ## Natural invoke - "Review this manuscript like peer reviewers" - "Focus only on methodology and statistics" - "Check whether my revisions address the comments" - "Calibrate the review rubric against a known decision set" ## Inputs to confirm - **Manuscript** - project manuscript directory or provided paper file. - **Mode** - full, quick, methodology-focus, re-review, or calibration. - **Review lens** - target venue, discipline, methods, and known reviewer comments. - **Evidence access** - rendered PDF, source markdown, output artifacts, validation reports, and claim ledgers. ## Workflow 1. **Read-only boundary** - produce reports, matrices, and recommendations only; route edits to [academic-paper](../academic-paper/SKILL.md). 2. **Panel lenses** - separate contribution, methods, evidence/citations, presentation, reproducibility, and adversarial-overclaim checks. 3. **Evidence audit** - cite source file paths, generated artifacts, evidence registry entries, and validation reports when flagging issues. 4. **Revision traceability** - in re-review mode, map each reviewer concern to author action, verification status, residual risk, and next owner. 5. **No sycophantic concession** - do not soften a finding unless new evidence from the manuscript or artifacts resolves it. ## Deliverables - Review package: s...