rebuttal

Featured

Prepare a paper for peer review. Reads the paper and experiment results, selects the strongest ablations, anticipates reviewer questions, finds weaknesses before submission, and drafts rebuttals to actual reviews. Use when the user asks about "reviewer questions", "anticipate reviewers", "rebuttal", "paper weaknesses", "defend the paper", "strengthen the paper", "select the strongest ablations", "fortify the paper", or "prepare for peer review".

AI & Automation 468 stars 39 forks Updated 2 days ago MIT

Install

View on GitHub

Quality Score: 94/100

Stars 20%
89
Recency 20%
100
Frontmatter 20%
70
Documentation 15%
100
Issue Health 10%
50
License 10%
100
Description 5%
100

Skill Content

# Rebuttal: Prepare for Peer Review Venue: $ARGUMENTS ## Step 1: Read the Paper and Results Discover the paper, result and config files as in Step 1 (Discover Files) of `/labrat:paper-check`, including wandb logs and checkpoint directories. Then list the paper's claims (contributions and experiments), its metrics and baselines, and every available run and its outcome, including the ablation variants the configs define. ## Step 2: Vulnerability Analysis Identify weaknesses from a reviewer's perspective: ### Technical Weaknesses - Missing baselines that reviewers would expect - Evaluation metrics that don't fully capture the contribution - Assumptions stated without justification - Scalability or generalization concerns not addressed - Missing error analysis or failure case discussion ### Presentation Weaknesses - Claims stronger than evidence supports - Missing related work that a reviewer in the area would know - Unclear methodology (could someone reimplement from the paper alone?) - Figures that don't clearly convey the intended message - Inconsistencies between sections ### Experimental Weaknesses - Small dataset size without justification - Missing statistical significance tests - No comparison with state-of-the-art on standard benchmarks - Hyperparameter sensitivity not explored - No computational cost comparison ## Step 3: Venue-Specific Anticipation If a venue was given, use its matching entry below. **Top-tier ML/CV conferences (CVPR, NeurIPS, ICLR, ECCV)**:...

Details

Author
fcakyon
Repository
fcakyon/labrat
Created
8 months ago
Last Updated
2 days ago
Language
Python
License
MIT

Similar Skills

Semantically similar based on skill content — not just same category